Shelley and the Marriage Question   By: John Todhunter (1839-1916)

Shelley and the Marriage Question by John Todhunter is a thought-provoking exploration of the complexities and contradictions surrounding love, marriage, and societal expectations during the Romantic era. In this insightful analysis, Todhunter shines a light on one of the most passionate and controversial figures of the time: Percy Bysshe Shelley.

The book delves into the intimate details of Shelley's life, examining his relationships, tumultuous marriage to Harriet Westbrook, and his subsequent partnership with Mary Shelley. Todhunter presents the reader with a comprehensive picture of how Shelley's unconventional views on marriage challenged the norms of society, leading him to question traditional gender roles, monogamy, and the institution of marriage itself.

What sets this book apart is Todhunter's exquisite command of the subject matter. His extensive research is evident in the detailed descriptions of Shelley's personal correspondence and literary works, providing readers with a deep understanding of the poet's mindset and motivations. Additionally, Todhunter contextualizes Shelley's ideas within the societal and philosophical climate of the time, shedding light on the broader significance of his dissenting views.

The author's prose, although dense at times, is engaging and thoughtfully constructed. It seamlessly weaves together historical analysis, literary criticism, and biographical elements, painting a vivid portrait of Shelley and the era in which he lived. Both scholars and casual readers with an interest in the Romantic period will appreciate the wealth of information and insight this book offers.

One aspect that deserves particular praise is Todhunter's ability to navigate the fine line between admiration and critical analysis of Shelley's ideas. While he acknowledges the brilliance and visionary nature of many of Shelley's thoughts, his objective approach allows for a balanced examination of their limitations and contradictions. This nuanced interpretation adds depth to the narrative, making it more than just a hagiography of Shelley.

Despite its many strengths, one minor drawback of this book is its occasional tangents and digressions, which can disrupt the flow of the overall narrative. While these diversions are often interesting in their own right, they may leave readers wanting a more focused exploration of Shelley's views on marriage.

In conclusion, Shelley and the Marriage Question is an excellent resource for anyone seeking a comprehensive understanding of Percy Bysshe Shelley's beliefs on love and marriage. John Todhunter's meticulous research and insightful analysis bring depth and nuance to the topic, inviting readers to reevaluate their own preconceptions and beliefs. This book is a valuable addition to the canon of Romantic literature and a must-read for scholars and enthusiasts alike.

First Page:

The very idea of marriage implies some kind of bond imposed by society upon the sexual relations of its members, male and female; some kind of restriction upon the absolute promiscuity and absolute instability of these relations such restriction taking the form of a contract between individuals, endorsed by society, and enforced with more or less stringency by public opinion... Continue reading book >>