The Beginnings of New England Or the Puritan Theocracy in its Relations to Civil and Religious Liberty   By: John Fiske (1842-1901)

The Beginnings of New England Or the Puritan Theocracy in its Relations to Civil and Religious Liberty by John Fiske is an exceptional piece of historical literature that delves deep into the early years of colonization in America. Fiske's meticulous research and comprehensive analysis shed light on the formation of New England, particularly the influence of the Puritans and their theocratic system.

One of the book's greatest strengths is Fiske's ability to provide a balanced account of the Puritans' arrival and subsequent development in New England. He explores both the positive and negative aspects of their theocratic governance, allowing readers to understand the complexity of the Puritan experience. Fiske also emphasizes the importance of examining historical events through the lens of their contemporary context, avoiding the trap of imposing modern moral judgments on the past.

Moreover, Fiske's writing style is captivating and accessible, making The Beginnings of New England a compelling read for both scholars and general readers interested in American history. He seamlessly weaves together primary sources, personal anecdotes, and his own insightful commentary to create a narrative that is both informative and engaging. Fiske's passion for his subject matter is evident throughout the book, and his enthusiasm is contagious.

Another commendable aspect of Fiske's work is his exploration of the Puritans' complicated relationship with civil and religious liberties. He examines how the Puritan theocracy, while initially striving for religious freedom, eventually became an oppressive regime that restricted individual liberties. Fiske argues that this transformation was not inevitable, but rather the result of specific historical circumstances, such as the threat of external forces and internal power struggles. This nuanced analysis adds depth and nuance to the portrayal of the Puritans, avoiding simplistic caricatures.

However, a small criticism would be that at times, Fiske's extensive use of primary sources and historical details can be overwhelming for readers who are less familiar with the subject matter. Occasionally, the narrative becomes bogged down in excessive details, making it harder to follow the overall argument. Nonetheless, this is a minor flaw in an otherwise outstanding work.

Overall, The Beginnings of New England Or the Puritan Theocracy in its Relations to Civil and Religious Liberty is a meticulously researched and thought-provoking book that offers a comprehensive understanding of the formation of New England and the Puritans' role in it. Fiske's ability to analyze historical events within their contemporary context, combined with his engaging writing style, makes this book a must-read for anyone interested in the history of America's early colonization and the complexities of religious and civil liberties.

First Page:

In this sketch of the circumstances which attended the settlement of New England, I have purposely omitted many details which in a formal history of that period would need to be included... Continue reading book >>