The Right of American Slavery   By: T. W. (True Worthy) Hoit (1815-)

In "The Right of American Slavery" by T. W. (True Worthy) Hoit, the author provides a comprehensive and controversial examination of the institution of slavery in the United States. Published in 1859, this book delves deeply into the arguments supporting and justifying the existence of slavery, presenting them from a perspective that was widely accepted in the South during that era.

Hoit begins by presenting a historical analysis of various civilizations throughout time that practiced slavery, aiming to highlight the prevalence of the institution across different cultures. He then proceeds to argue that slavery is in alignment with natural laws and biblical teachings, attempting to demonstrate that it is a morally acceptable social structure. By doing so, Hoit presents a defense of slavery that is primarily built upon religious and philosophical grounds.

One of the strengths of this book is its thorough exploration of the justifications used by proponents of slavery. Hoit meticulously examines legal, economic, social, and even theological arguments, aiming to provide a comprehensive understanding of the complex reasons behind the perpetuation of this inhumane system. This analysis offers readers insight into the mindset of those who believed in the inherent rightness of owning slaves.

Furthermore, the book provides an important historical context that helps readers understand the perspectives of the time. Hoit draws extensively from both primary and secondary sources, including ancient philosophical texts, legal documents, and religious scriptures, to bolster his arguments. This approach enhances the credibility of his claims, as he relies on widely recognized sources to support his position.

However, it is crucial to acknowledge the inherent biases present in "The Right of American Slavery." Hoit approaches the subject matter from a pro-slavery standpoint, which inevitably shapes his arguments and analysis. The book lacks critical examination of alternative perspectives or the experiences of enslaved individuals, focusing primarily on justifying the institution through legal and philosophical frameworks. This lack of balance in the narrative may limit readers' ability to develop a well-rounded understanding of the complexities and atrocities of slavery.

Overall, "The Right of American Slavery" by T. W. (True Worthy) Hoit is a significant historical document that sheds light on the arguments used to endorse and legitimize the institution of slavery in the United States. The book provides an invaluable resource for understanding the ideas and beliefs of those who supported this oppressive system. However, it is essential to approach this work critically and with an awareness of its inherent bias, as it fails to offer a comprehensive examination of the human suffering endured by enslaved individuals.

First Page:

My Fellow Countrymen: Upon what manner of times have we fallen? Is our supposed experiment of self government about to prove a failure? Are we so blind as not to see the abyss into which we are about to plunge? Section hostile against section; States arrayed against the Constitution; Churches sundered; the springs of intelligence poisoned at their source; treason stalking... Continue reading book >>