Primitive Christian Worship Or, The Evidence of Holy Scripture and the Church, Against the Invocation of Saints and Angels, and the Blessed Virgin Mary   By: James Endell Tyler (1789-1851)

In "Primitive Christian Worship," James Endell Tyler skillfully presents a comprehensive analysis of the controversial topic of the invocation of saints, angels, and the Virgin Mary. With a dedicated focus on Holy Scripture and the historical practices of the early Christian Church, the author mounts a compelling argument against these religious traditions.

Tyler's expertise shines through in his meticulous examination of biblical texts, where he deftly highlights the absence of any explicit scriptural endorsement of invoking saints, angels, or the Virgin Mary. Drawing on an extensive array of passages, he effectively challenges the theological justifications and doctrinal interpretations that have been traditionally employed to support these practices.

The strength of the book lies in Tyler's careful consideration of historical evidence. He delves into the rich tapestry of early Christian worship, drawing upon the writings of Church Fathers and other early Christian sources. By examining practices from the first few centuries, Tyler illuminates the gradual emergence and evolution of the invocation of saints, angels, and the Virgin Mary, ultimately arguing that these practices were inventions of a later period.

Moreover, Tyler dutifully addresses possible objections to his arguments, skillfully presenting counterarguments and providing meaningful explanations. This nuanced approach adds depth to his analysis, showing a commitment to comprehensively exploring the issue rather than resorting to oversimplifications or dismissals.

The author's writing style is clear and accessible, making this weighty theological work digestible even to readers who may not possess an extensive background in Christian history or scriptural exegesis. Tyler effortlessly guides the reader through complex ideas, skillfully leading them to his own conclusions while respecting differing perspectives.

While Tyler's arguments are undeniably persuasive, it would have been beneficial to see more engagement with opposing viewpoints. Although he addresses counterarguments to some extent, a more thorough examination of alternative interpretations and defenses of invocation practices would have further enriched the dialogue.

Overall, "Primitive Christian Worship" is an intellectually stimulating and well-researched exploration of a contentious religious issue. Tyler's erudition and meticulous analysis shed light on this topic, offering a valuable resource for scholars, theologians, and individuals interested in understanding the historical foundations of Christian worship.

First Page:

Members of the Church of Rome, and members of the Church of England, have too long entertained towards each other feelings of hostility. Instead of being drawn together as brethren by the cords of that one faith which all Catholics hold dear, their sentiments of sympathy and affection have been absorbed by the abhorrence with which each body has regarded the characteristic tenets of its adversary; whilst the terms "heretic" on the one side, and "idolater" on the opposite, have rendered any attempt to bring about a free and friendly discussion of each other's views almost hopeless... Continue reading book >>