The Grounds of an Opinion on the Policy of Restricting the Importation of Foreign Corn: intended as an appendix to "Observations on the corn laws"   By: Thomas R. Malthus (1766-1834)

In "The Grounds of an Opinion on the Policy of Restricting the Importation of Foreign Corn," Thomas R. Malthus presents a thought-provoking appendix to his previous work, "Observations on the corn laws." Malthus, known for his influential theories on population and economic growth, delves deep into the issue of restricting the importation of foreign corn in this book, providing readers with a comprehensive analysis of the policy’s impact on both national and international levels.

The strengths of Malthus' argument lie in his rigorous research and logical reasoning. Drawing upon historical examples, statistical data, and economic principles, he constructs a solid foundation to support his position. Malthus carefully dissects the interplay between domestic production and imported corn, shedding light on the potential consequences of restrictive policies. By highlighting the delicate balance between self-sufficiency and international trade, he challenges readers to reconsider traditional notions surrounding protectionism.

Throughout the book, Malthus consistently demonstrates his ability to present complex ideas in a clear and accessible manner. The clarity of his writing ensures that readers from various backgrounds can engage with the subject matter. Moreover, his logical progression of arguments allows for seamless comprehension and facilitates a deeper understanding of the intricacies of the corn laws and their underlying principles.

One notable aspect of Malthus' work is his acknowledgement of the multifaceted nature of the issue at hand. He recognizes that the policy of restricting the importation of foreign corn has far-reaching effects on different stakeholders, such as farmers, consumers, and the government. Malthus takes great care in evaluating the potential implications for each group, seeking a holistic solution rather than merely advocating for a particular interest. This comprehensive approach helps create a balanced and inclusive perspective that significantly enhances the overall credibility of his argument.

However, despite its strengths, "The Grounds of an Opinion on the Policy of Restricting the Importation of Foreign Corn" does have some limitations. The book occasionally dwells too much on repetitive arguments, which can lead to a sense of redundancy and detract from the overall reading experience. Additionally, given the age of the text and the advancements in economic theory since its publication, some readers may find certain sections outdated. While Malthus's contributions remain valuable and influential, it is important to approach the text with a critical eye.

Overall, "The Grounds of an Opinion on the Policy of Restricting the Importation of Foreign Corn" is a highly informative and meticulously researched appendix that enriches the discourse surrounding the corn laws. Malthus skillfully dissects the policy from various angles and presents a persuasive case that challenges conventional wisdom. The book will undoubtedly appeal to those interested in economics, trade, and the intersection of domestic and international policies.

First Page:

A fair review of both sides of the question, without any attempt to conceal the peculiar evils, whether temporary or permanent, which might belong to each, appeared to me of use, not only to assist in forming an enlightened decision on the subject, but particularly to prepare the public for the specific consequences which were to be expected from that decision, on whatever side it might be made. Such a preparation, from some quarter or other, seemed to be necessary, to prevent those just discontents which would naturally have arisen, if the measure adopted had been attended with results very different from those which had been promised by its advocates, or contemplated by the legislature... Continue reading book >>